Main content | Sidebar | Links

Tuesday, July 20, 2004

Deliberate failure.

Here's the tail end of Thomas Frank's op-ed in Friday's New York Times on the Senate's "pseudopopulist theater" concerning a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage or anything remotely like it:

Of course, as everyone pointed out, the whole enterprise was doomed to failure from the start. It didn't have to be that way; conservatives could have chosen any number of more promising avenues to challenge or limit the Massachusetts ruling. Instead they went with a constitutional amendment, the one method where failure was absolutely guaranteed — along with front-page coverage

Then again, what culture war offensive isn't doomed to failure from the start? Indeed, the inevitability of defeat seems to be a critical element of the melodrama, on issues from school prayer to evolution and even abortion.

Failure on the cultural front serves to magnify the outrage felt by conservative true believers; it mobilizes the base. Failure sharpens the distinctions between conservatives and liberals. Failure allows for endless grandstanding without any real-world consequences that might upset more moderate Republicans or the party's all-important corporate wing. You might even say that grand and garish defeat — especially if accompanied by the ridicule of the sophisticated — is the culture warrior's very object.

The issue is all-important; the issue is incapable of being won. Only when the battle is defined this way can it achieve the desired results, have its magical polarizing effect. Only with a proposed constitutional amendment could the legalistic, cavilling Democrats be counted on to vote "no," and only with an offensive so blunt and so sweeping could the universal hostility of the press be secured.

Losing is prima facie evidence that the basic conservative claim is true: that the country is run by liberals; that the world is unfair; that the majority is persecuted by a sinister elite. And that therefore you, my red-state friend, had better get out there and vote as if your civilization depended on it.

("Failure is not an option, it's mandatory," Thomas Frank, New York Times 7.16.04, reg req'd; via Tapped)

Copyright © 2004 by Philocrites | Posted 20 July 2004 at 5:03 PM

Previous: Theological diversity watch.
Next: Unitarian Universalists for Kerry.




Comments for this entry are currently closed.